This example looks at the problem of assigning swimmers to strokes based on their best times. However, in this case certain swimmers are not eligible to perform certain strokes. A missing (.) value in the data matrix identifies an ineligible assignment. For example:
data RelayTimesMatrix; input name $ sex $ back breast fly free; datalines; Sue F . 36.7 28.3 36.1 Karen F 34.6 . . 26.2 Jan F 31.3 . 27.1 . Andrea F 28.6 . 29.1 . Carol F 32.9 . 26.6 . ;
Recall that the linear assignment problem can also be interpreted as the minimum-weight matching in a bipartite graph. The eligible assignments define links between the rows (swimmers) and the columns (strokes), as in Output 2.4.1.
Output 2.4.1: Bipartite Graph for Linear Assignment Problem
Because of this, you can represent the same data in RelayTimesMatrix
with a links data set as follows:
data RelayTimesLinks; input name $ attr $ cost; datalines; Sue breast 36.7 Sue fly 28.3 Sue free 36.1 Karen back 34.6 Karen free 26.2 Jan back 31.3 Jan fly 27.1 Andrea back 28.6 Andrea fly 29.1 Carol back 32.9 Carol fly 26.6 ;
This graph must be bipartite (such that and are disjoint); if it is not, PROC OPTNET returns an error.
Now, you can use either input format to solve the same problem as follows:
proc optnet data_matrix = RelayTimesMatrix; linear_assignment out = LinearAssignMatrix weight = (back--free) id = (name sex); run; proc optnet graph_direction = directed data_links = RelayTimesLinks; data_links_var from = name to = attr weight = cost; linear_assignment out = LinearAssignLinks; run;
When you use the graph input format, the LINEAR_ASSIGNMENT options WEIGHT= and ID= are not used directly.
The data sets LinearAssignMatrix
and LinearAssignLinks
now contain the optimal assignments, as shown in Output 2.4.2 and Output 2.4.3.
Output 2.4.2: Optimal Assignments for Swim Times (Dense Input)
name | sex | assign | cost |
---|---|---|---|
Sue | F | breast | 36.7 |
Karen | F | free | 26.2 |
Andrea | F | back | 28.6 |
Carol | F | fly | 26.6 |
118.1 |
Output 2.4.3: Optimal Assignments for Swim Times (Sparse Input)
name | attr | cost |
---|---|---|
Sue | breast | 36.7 |
Karen | free | 26.2 |
Andrea | back | 28.6 |
Carol | fly | 26.6 |
118.1 |
The optimal assignments are shown graphically in Output 2.4.4.
Output 2.4.4: Optimal Assignments for Swim Times
For large problems where a number of links are forbidden, the sparse format can be faster and can save a great deal of memory. Consider an example that uses the format of the DATA_MATRIX= option with 15,000 columns () and 4,000 rows (). To store the dense matrix in memory, PROC OPTNET needs to allocate approximately MB. If the data have mostly ineligible links, then the sparse (graph) format that uses the DATA_LINKS= option is much more efficient with respect to memory. For example, if the data have only 5% of the eligible links (), then the dense storage would still need 457 MB, while the sparse storage needs approximately MB. If the problem is fully dense (all links are eligible), then the dense format that uses the DATA_MATRIX= option is the most efficient.